September 19 - December 19

Mardi Gras Murder

FROLIC CABARET

Mardi Gras Murder

with Macy Campbell , Nathan Hach , Mia Kardotzke , Mark Vandevender , Robert Walland and Michael Rogaliner (Writer/Director/Producer) & John DiSanto (Music Director)
Crime Solving, Food & Entertainment
A Pickwick Murder Mystery

Inspired by the Songs of Billy Joel

These just may be the lunatics you're looking for!

Written & Directed by MICHAEL ROGALINER

Music Directed by JOHN DiSANTO

***
Fresh salad, warm dinner rolls and a cocktail menu are waiting for you at your seats. The cast visits your table to sign up volunteers for a limited number of contests and karaoke slots. Act One begins with a song at 7:30pm and ends around 8pm with our famous audience-led karaoke sing-along. Dinner is served.

Twenty minutes later the Mystery and Fun continue in Act Two followed by a short break for table deliberations, voting and dessert.

Act Three culminates in the reveal of the killer. After bows, the winning table leaders are invited to the stage to compete for prizes by answering questions about the show followed by pictures with the cast.

***

**Service charge includes performance staff dinner service and ticket processing**

Murder Mystery Menu 1st Course

Field greens salad with cucumber, carrots, tomatoes & balsamic vinaigrette dressing

Freshly baked rolls & whipped butter

2nd Course

Your choice of entrée:

Strip Loin

topped with mushroom demi-glaze, served with mashed potatoes & sautéed vegetable medley

Chicken Parmesan

with penne marinara

Oven Roasted Haddock

buttered breadcrumb topping and chimichurri sauce, served with mashed potatoes & sautéed vegetable medley

Vegan Stuffed Pepper

stuffed with a mixture of mushrooms, rice & lentils served with spaghetti squash and marinara

Penne Pasta with Marinara

3rd Course

Lemon Olive Oil Cake (If Vegan, please ask your server for our Vegan Chocolate Brownie)

* All menu selections are subject to change. *

****21 and Over****
**PLEASE CALL THE BOX OFFICE IF YOU WISH TO BE SEATED WITH A SPECIFIC PARTY**
**COMMUNAL SEATING / SOCIAL EXPERIENCE**
SEATING WILL BEGIN 30 MINUTES PRIOR TO SHOWTIME

Macy Campbell

MACY CAMPBELL (Alice Brown) is a 2021 graduate of Ashland University with a BA in Musical Theatre. This is her sixth consecutive show at Pickwick & Frolic after originating the roles of Sandy Hart in Bachelorettes Overboard!, Hallmark star Svetlana Toy in Murder at Celebrity Rehab, Lydia in The Scientology Killer and Honey Rodgers in The Sitcom Killer as well as playing Nurse Lisa in the hit revival of Psych Ward Whacker. Other roles include Sophie in Mamma Mia!, Caroline and Amy in The Theory of Relativity and Irina in Three Sisters. She would like to thank her family and friends. Enjoy the show!

Nathan Hach

NATHAN HACH (Barney) is back at Pickwick after playing Dr. Carl Genius in last season’s hit murder mystery Psych Ward Whacker. He is best known for his roles in the independent films Disconnected and My Summer in Ohio and his voice is featured in the video games Celestial Crowns and The Pretender’s Guild. He previously appeared at Pickwick in Serial Bachelorette Killer, #Killbridezilla, Murder at Celebrity Rehab, The Scientology Killer, The Sitcom Killer and Bachelorettes Overboard!

Mia Kardotzke

MIA KARDOTZKE (Tessa Tickle) is a musical theatre graduate from Ashland University. She's back on the Frolic Cabaret Stage after playing Amy Hatem in last season’s hit murder mystery Psych Ward Whacker and having originated the roles of Cleo in Murder at Celebrity Rehab, Jazzy Howell in The Scientology Killer, Denise Starr in The Sitcom Killer and Joan Creek in Bachelorettes Overboard! Mia has starred in a variety of shows including Mamma Mia! (Donna), Enemy of the People (Peter/Petrine), Twelfth Night (Olivia) and Theory of Relativity (Catherine/Jenny). She gives a huge shoutout to her family, friends and all who have supported her throughout the years.

Mark Vandevender

MARK VANDEVENDER (Cooter) is back at Pickwick after having played Ellery Dickery in last season’s hit murder mystery Psych Ward Whacker and having originated the role of Capt. Dick Hudson in Bachelorettes Overboard! Some recent credentials include performing on the dance team in Head over Heels, Rocky in The Rocky Horror Picture Show, Kurt in Heathers and Sky in Mamma Mia. He has performed in many murder mysteries around the area and wants to thank his supportive family and friends! Enjoy the show!

Robert Walland

Robert Walland (Parker Brown) is excited to be back on the Pickwick stage after previously originating the roles of Joe in Bachelorettes Gone Homicidal, Officer Gary in The All-Girl Prison Murders, S. Umpleby in High School Reunion Homicide and Pistol Farkas in The Sitcom Killer, as well as hosting The Hump Day Show for Hilarities. A Cleveland area native, Robert has also spent time performing stand-up comedy, improv and appearing in commercial and film projects throughout Northeast Ohio. He’s thrilled to be back with Pickwick in front of a live audience where every performance is a little different and anything can happen.

Michael Rogaliner (Writer/Director/Producer) & John DiSanto (Music Director)

Michael Rogaliner (Writer/Director/Producer) and John DiSanto (Music Director) have created and produced entertainment for Pickwick & Frolic since it opened in 2002 helping to fulfill owner Nick Kostis' vision of the Frolic Cabaret as a showcase for extraordinary local talent. Their stage shows include multi-year runs of The Midnight Martini Show, Cabaret Rock, Burlesque and The Delusional Divas of Drag as well as a sold-out run of the Off-Broadway musical Forever Plaid. Their Murder Mystery Dinner Parties have delighted audiences for over 18 years with their looney mix of comedy, music and audience participation.

Seating in the showroom begins at least 45 minutes prior to showtime.

Yes. Just provide your ID or the Credit Card used to purchase the tickets on the way in. We do not allow print at home tickets to avoid 3rd party ticket sellers.

Premium tickets guarantee seating in the first 6 rows from the stage and may include other perks depending on the act. General Admission seating is behind Premium and is sat on a first come basis.

Typically shows are 1st come, 1st seated within the section that was purchased, so we encourage you to arrive when doors open so you have seating options. We cannot hold seats for anyone that has yet to arrive.

Of course! You can purchase gift cards here or in person at the Box Office. Your gift card can be used for food and beverage anywhere in the building and can also be used to purchase tickets both online and at the Box Office.

Have more questions? Visit our full FAQ page!

12/05/2026 7:30 PM

Door Time: 7:00 PM

Other Showtimes

CRIME SOLVING, FOOD & ENTERTAINMENT

Mardi Gras Murder

Pickwick’s Newest Murder Mystery Dinner Party

A controversial mystery writer tackles his biggest whodunnit yet when a Voodoo man predicts his murder in New Orleans.

Written & Directed by MICHAEL ROGALINER

Music Directed by JOHN DiSANTO

AUDIENCE KARAOKE CHOICES
(Song lengths are 1 verse & 1 refrain. Subject to change.)
My Guy * Hound Dog * I Gotta Feeling * Mamma Mia * Man I Feel Like a Woman * Love Shack * New York New York * You’re the One That I Want * These Boots Were Made For Walking * Get the Party Started * Like a Virgin * I Will Survive * Single Ladies * Shake It Off * Respect * Before He Cheats * YMCA * Sweet Caroline.

CONTESTS
Mardi Gras King
Mardi Gras Murder Trivia

***Please be advised that there will be flashing lights and a simulated gun shot.***

***
Fresh salad, warm dinner rolls and a cocktail menu are waiting for you at your seats.  The cast visits your table to sign up volunteers for a limited number of contests and karaoke slots. Act One begins with a song at 7:30pm and ends around 8pm with our famous audience-led karaoke sing-along.  Dinner is served.

Twenty minutes later the Mystery and Fun continue in Act Two followed by a short break for table deliberations, voting and dessert.

Act Three culminates in the reveal of the killer.  After bows, the winning table leaders are invited to the stage to compete for prizes by answering questions about the show followed by pictures with the cast.​

***

**Service charge includes performance staff dinner service and ticket processing**

***

Murder Mystery Menu

1st Course

Field Greens Salad with cucumber, carrots, tomatoes & balsamic vinaigrette (gf)

Freshly baked Rolls & whipped butter

2nd Course

Your choice of entrée:

Rotisserie Roasted Prime Rib of Beef, Au jus

Mashed Potatoes and Seasonal Vegetables

Hot Honey Glazed Salmon

Mashed Potatoes and Seasonal Vegetables

Chicken Piccata

White Wine Lemon-butter, Capers, Mashed potatoes and Seasonal Vegetables

Vegan Stuffed Pepper

Stuffed with a mixture of Mushroom, Rice and Lentil.  Spaghetti Squash and House-made Marinara

3rd Course

NY Style Cheesecake topped with fresh berry compote or Vegan Brownie on request

****21 and Over****
**PLEASE CALL THE BOX OFFICE IF YOU WISH TO BE SEATED WITH A SPECIFIC PARTY**
**COMMUNAL SEATING / SOCIAL EXPERIENCE**
SEATING WILL BEGIN 30 MINUTES PRIOR TO SHOWTIME

Ticket Resale Policy

Seating in the showroom begins at least 45 minutes prior to showtime.

Yes. Just provide your ID or the Credit Card used to purchase the tickets on the way in. We do not allow print at home tickets to avoid 3rd party ticket sellers.

Premium tickets guarantee seating in the first 6 rows from the stage and may include other perks depending on the act. General Admission seating is behind Premium and is sat on a first come basis.

Typically shows are 1st come, 1st seated within the section that was purchased, so we encourage you to arrive when doors open so you have seating options. We cannot hold seats for anyone that has yet to arrive.

Of course! You can purchase gift cards here or in person at the Box Office. Your gift card can be used for food and beverage anywhere in the building and can also be used to purchase tickets both online and at the Box Office.

Have more questions? Visit our full FAQ page!

Crime Solving, Food & Entertainment
A Pickwick Murder Mystery

Inspired by the Songs of Billy Joel

These just may be the lunatics you're looking for!

Written & Directed by MICHAEL ROGALINER

Music Directed by JOHN DiSANTO

***
Fresh salad, warm dinner rolls and a cocktail menu are waiting for you at your seats. The cast visits your table to sign up volunteers for a limited number of contests and karaoke slots. Act One begins with a song at 7:30pm and ends around 8pm with our famous audience-led karaoke sing-along. Dinner is served.

Twenty minutes later the Mystery and Fun continue in Act Two followed by a short break for table deliberations, voting and dessert.

Act Three culminates in the reveal of the killer. After bows, the winning table leaders are invited to the stage to compete for prizes by answering questions about the show followed by pictures with the cast.

***

**Service charge includes performance staff dinner service and ticket processing**

Murder Mystery Menu 1st Course

Field greens salad with cucumber, carrots, tomatoes & balsamic vinaigrette dressing

Freshly baked rolls & whipped butter

2nd Course

Your choice of entrée:

Strip Loin

topped with mushroom demi-glaze, served with mashed potatoes & sautéed vegetable medley

Chicken Parmesan

with penne marinara

Oven Roasted Haddock

buttered breadcrumb topping and chimichurri sauce, served with mashed potatoes & sautéed vegetable medley

Vegan Stuffed Pepper

stuffed with a mixture of mushrooms, rice & lentils served with spaghetti squash and marinara

Penne Pasta with Marinara

3rd Course

Lemon Olive Oil Cake (If Vegan, please ask your server for our Vegan Chocolate Brownie)

* All menu selections are subject to change. *

****21 and Over****
**PLEASE CALL THE BOX OFFICE IF YOU WISH TO BE SEATED WITH A SPECIFIC PARTY**
**COMMUNAL SEATING / SOCIAL EXPERIENCE**
SEATING WILL BEGIN 30 MINUTES PRIOR TO SHOWTIME

Macy Campbell

Nathan Hach

Mia Kardotzke

Mark Vandevender

Robert Walland

Michael Rogaliner (Writer/Director/Producer) & John DiSanto (Music Director)